|
Welcome,
Guest
|
|
|
just wondering if a hydroponic light fixture would be ok for a large tank....
like this...Sun Blaze 432W 6500K 40000 Lumens 4FT T5 Fluorescent Grow Light 199$ ??? im thinking like a 150gal++ thinking of trying to get finances together for a large rimless like 48x36x24 |
|
Last Edit: 3 years ago by j66213b.
|
|
those are no different from "aquarium" lights in terms of light output. You put the same bulbs in there as in an equivilant "aquarium" fixture and you'll get the same light. With several major caveats.
1: Moisture. Hydro lights aren't protected against it. Their housing isn't generally sealed as well, and they normally don't use waterproof endcaps, or the same grouding with their ballasts. This isn't a knock against these lights. For their use, they don't NEED the protection aquarium lights do. However, the first time you have to buy a new ballast for a hydro light because too much moisture got in the wrong place, you'll be mad you didn't spend a bit more and get one that was made for an aquarium. 2: Plugs and switches. Aquarium lights are almost always built (in the case of T5HO) to have only two bulbs (or four in the case of VERY large setups) running on any given plug or switch. This makes it to where you can run less bulbs when needed and run the whole she-bang for a noon-burst, or use certain color bulbs on one bank and another color on another bank that are run at seperate times, etc etc etc. There are many reasons for the banks of lights to be on seperate plugs, timers, etc and I wouldn't want a light where I didn't have that control. ESPECIALLY a T5HO. They are very powerful, given the right bulbs, and most tanks (freshwater) with average depth and height don't NEED any more than two T5HO bulbs down the length of the tank to grow *most* plants. Four bulb fixtures are very nice to run two bulbs most of the day and all four for a burst to get a little more punch from the light. You couldn't do that with most hydro lights. 3: Quality. High-tech planted tank owners whined enough to get light fixture makers to create planted tank lights with very nice quality. Any light that doesn't meet these standards is immediately renounced on forums all over the world lol. I don't agree with this particular strategy, but it has paved the way for nice lights at decent prices. I'm not going to come out and say it, but Tek lights (and a few other nice lights out there) are for big nurseries looking to grow plants hydroponically and be successful in their field. Cut-rate "hydro" lights are for a whole other "business" and they aren't made with the same standards. Generally, the majority of their customers don't scientifically know the difference between two lights, and are simply looking for the cheapest way to set up a growing room. I'm not saying don't get this light, as it might just work for you. However, the differences above would probably make me go somewhere that is reputable while at the same time being cost effective and tailors specifically to your needs. Catalina Aquariums has a very good rep for this purpose. AH Supply does too. (although they deal exclusively in power compact the last time I checked) Current USA is another, although they're a smidge more expensive, and I've heard a few more complaints about their lights. you decide, I'm just blabbing lol how deep is your 150? For anything but the very deepest of tanks a 4 bulb (4 x 54W) T5HO fixture would work fine, and Catalina Aquariums has theirs on sale for $200shipped. I ordered one just today lol. |
|
|
|
i was looking at allglasscages website im not sure yet this will be a "future" project and just want to get my prices down... also planning on going w/ and ADA aquasoil base (not sure on the cap) but just trying to get $$ figured out b/c the tank and stand will be over a grand and i have the filter and co2.. so i need the lighting prices to figure out... and if im going to do inline heating and UV.... not sure debating... on everything i figure if im throwing in the $$ might as well make sure i get quality stuff... also would MH lights be better for this or T5HO? i have seen alot of cool set ups w/ MH lights...
|
|
|
|
I haven't used MH lights before. They are a point source, so they abide by the inverse square law, vs. a linear source (T5HO) which does not. This just means that the deeper the tank, the better T5HO is vs. MH. Technically the "best" would be a pendant with MH and T5HO as well, but for my money MH is a waste when T5HO exists. I will admit that MH looks so much cooler though. Gets that awesome ripple effect with the bouncing shadows throughout your tank, but that's just aesthetics, and can be achieved much cheaper. MH bulbs are also darned expensive to replace, and don't last anywhere near as long as T5HO. If you want "quality" in T5HO GUARANTEED? Go with a Tek light system. The price can be beat but the quality can't. But I can buy several Chevys for the price of a Rolls Royce
If your tank width is really big (36" you said?) you should look into a retro kit. You can spread out the bulbs a bit more to cover the tank better and it'll save you some money. You'd have to build your own hood, but that's kind of what a project's all about right? |
|
|
|
Building a light fixture isn't that hard. I built mine out of aluminum that was bent to the shape I wanted. Some day I might paint them black.
Each one houses 4 36" 39W T5HO bulbs ran by the IceCaps 660 ballast. Each ballast runs 2 lights in each fixture. This way I'm not running all eight bulbs all the time. Still playing with the amount of time I run all eight bulbs. My first fixture was made out of wood and was way too heavy. I also used cheaper ballast the first time around. Wasn't too happy with their quality so I went with the IceCaps. The run allot cooler plus they don't have to be mounted in the fixture. They are inside the cabinet. I can post some pics of my fixtures if you like. |
|
|
|